The Not-So-Secret Alpha Weapon

As the equity markets around the world turned higher in Q1 2009, and were followed by the economy soon after, many investment managers began to lag the broad averages/benchmarks as a result of being defensive. (Can you blame them?) Figuring out how to play catch up was the question, and many investors turned to emerging markets as the secret weapon. And why not? The story sounded good. Most avoided the domestic financial crush simply by not having a banking system that could support leveraged “ponzi paper” that the US and Europe were good at creating. They didn’t have the same issue we had with deficits and housing. They did not avoid the global slowdown 100%, however, their growth potential as a whole looked outstanding as the world rebounded, and they were going to lead us out of the recession.

Emerging markets were going to be the next big thing in the investment world and the upside opportunity appeared limitless. The beta of these markets is historically higher than the developed markets, and as momentum turned it seemed like the perfect trade, creating an allocation opportunity to add portfolio alpha. Emerging markets’ correlation to US stocks grew, but who cares about diversification when everything is going up, right? ETFs became the vehicle of choice for investing in emerging markets and the growth in these products swelled, ultimately breaking into the top tier by fund assets, alongside the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) and the SPDR Gold Trust (GLD).

As 2010 was a grind up to new recovery highs was complete the tortoise (developed market equities) strolled passed the performance finish line ahead of the hare (emerging markets). But from the recovery lows the previous two years we still saw a large disparity in returns between these two brtheren. To be sure, the total return of the iShares MSCI Emerging Market Index (EEM) from the beginning of March 2009 through the end of 2010 was 131.5%. This compared to a 77.47% return for SPY and a similar 77.59% return for the iShares MSCI Developed Markets ETF (EFA) over the same period. As we enter 2011 and assets continue to balloon, fundamentals are no longer supporting such an large allocation to emerging markets versus developed markets as the recovery matures. The commodity story, which helped bolster resource-producing economies and their currencies, has become long in the tooth and political issues are causing excess volatility. Fundamentals do matter as do valuations. As the slow and steady improvement in the US economy hits stride, the surer bet right now is the tortoise. Year-to-date through 2/9/10 has said it all. EEM is down 4.47% compared to a 5.18% gain in SPY. As we review the fundamentals that drive US stocks, even after the lost decade, they are positively sloped and respond in kind to growing and improving economic fundamentals. This is not always the case (yet) for emerging economies. It has yet to be proven conclusively that these equity markets reflect their economies for any continued period. In fact, I am not even sure emerging market equities are positively sloped. They present great runs followed by almost equal declines. So as the train gets crowded and is about to leave the station, smart money is (or should be) rotating out of emerging equities and into more developed markets and larger capitalization stocks. There will be a place and time to re-enter emerging markets for the “beta trade”, but that may be a few quarters and maybe up to few dozen percentage points from here.